Jan. 16, 2010: Litigation Mounting Against DePuy for Defective Hip Implants
DePuy hip articular surface replacement (ASR) implant devices—the ASR Hip Resurfacing System and the ASR XL Acetabular System—which have been implanted in about 93,000 patients, were recalled in August 2010 following very high failure rates and ongoing reports of patients experiencing pain, discomfort, and problems with flexibility and walking. A design flaw in how the metal hip cup was created, in which the interior is insufficient to hold the hip's femoral portion, appears to be to blame.
"The defendants were aware of many complaints made to the Food and Drug Administration in the United States and Health Canada regarding the failure of the DePuy implants. These complaints included component loosening, misalignment, dislocation and fracture, and the creation of abnormal or excessive metal debris in the hip socket. This metal debris could spread to surrounding tissue, causing severe inflammation and damage. The failure of the DePuy implants often requires complicated, expensive and painful revision surgery to correct," alleged one Canadian plaintiff, Jo-Anne Scharf, in her lawsuit against the device maker, quoted the Chronicle Herald.
In addition to defect issues, DePuy did not maintain appropriate records of patients implanted with their faulty devices and, worse, has recently been found to be attending revision surgeries, possibly taking removed devices from operating rooms. Meanwhile, nearly half of all DePuy hip replacement patients have not been contacted by their surgeons, which means that many patients may be suffering the effects of defective implants unaware they may require revision surgery, a long and dangerous reimplantation on a joint that has less bone to work with due to what was removed for the original surgery.
If you or someone you know has been implanted with one of these defective devices, you should seek the advice of an attorney familar with the litigation against DePuy Orthopaedics. If you have been implanted with one of these defective devices, you should immediately seek advice from a lawyer that is knowledgeable about the DePuy hip implant recall and the injuries associated with these hip implants. For a free consultation with such an attorney, complete the form to the right or call 212-566-1000. Based in New York City, Sullivan & Brill, LLP represents clients throughout the United States.

Office Locations
New York
Trinity Centre
115 Broadway, 17th Floor
New York, NY 10006
(212) 566-1000
Puerto Rico
#73 Santa Cruz St., Suite 407
Santa Cruz Medical Building
Bayamon, Puerto Rico
Case Results
- $750,000 Settlement for Medical Malpractice Victim
- $500,000 Settlement for Victim of Sexual Assault
- $375,000 Settlement for Delayed Diagnosis of Ankle Fracture
- $350,000 Settlement for Failure to Diagnosis of Skin Cancer
- Jury Awards $320,000 to Women with Fractured Ankle
- $250,000 Settlement Obtained for Victim of False Arrest
- $200,000 Settlement Obtain for Family of Man that Committed Suicide
- $175,000 Settlement Obtained for Child that Sustained Hernia
- $135,000 Settlement for Injury from Fall in Store
- $130,000 Settlement for Women that Tripped on Sidewalk and Fractured Wrist
- Slip on Ice Causing Knee Injury Results in $95,000 Settlement
- $90,000 Settlement for Women with Herniated Disc
- $88,000 Settlement Obtained for Man Who Injured Wrist in Car Accident
- $80,000 Settlement for Women with Carpal Tunnel Syndrome


